Saving threatened habitats worldwide

Chris Packham and tiger extinction

8 June, 2010 - 11:21 -- John Burton

Last week's Radio Times featured an article by Chris Packham (link opens in a new window) suggesting that huge amounts of scarce conservation funding have been wasted on trying to save the tiger from extinction.  It is a fascinating and overall pretty good assessment of the situation.

Around 30 years ago I gave a paper at the annual conference of the British Association for the Advancement of Science on the theme of Future Extinctions. In this paper I pointed out that some species, including the California Condor, Giant Panda and Orang-utan were relicts of a Pleistocene Fauna, and as such were probably doomed to extinction; their range had been contracting for thousands of years and would probably continue to do so until they disappeared. Was it right to spend millions of dollars trying to prevent the inevitable, shouldn't we let them disappear  gracefully?

I was at that time the chief executive of what is now Fauna & Flora International. The reaction to this paper - which to put it into its context was  given at a Paleontology session, was pretty hysterical, and led to my chairman (Lord Craighton) being phoned by the chairman of WWF with demands for my resignation for being so apparently irresponsible.  Lord Craighton defended my position robustly, and after a flurry of correspondence in The Times, it was all forgotten.

Now nearly three decades on, while I still believe that some species are really past their sell by date, I have modified my views somewhat. I do think that tigers can survive, but only if we increase the area available, and also increase the corridors between them. Next time I see Chris Packham there should be an interesting discussion.

Comments

Submitted by Derek Remington on

I agree that Tiger conservation is not being successful. However only we humans can do anything about it. People should NOT be told to stop wasting their money.
I give slide talks on Butterfly conservation and give my fees to Lulworth ] but I also give talks on India and give my fees to The Satpuda Foundation, the Directors of which I have met in India. I have seen tigers and been to a few reserves.
I have sent copies of The Telegraph article all over the place including Born Free which supports Satpuda, Belinda Wright, the India Embassy and the Chinese Embassy.

Let us do it right not stop tiger conservation. It was voted the animal most worth saving on TV and the £600,000 was all sent to Nepal ! ! minus their overheads !

Submitted by Karen on

Who are we to pick and chose which species we should/shouldn't attempt to conserve for our children. We must try our best and give 100% to conservation efforts. To simply sigh and give up is a premature attitude of defeat. There are around 3000 tigers on earth, we owe it to them to support them while they stay on this planet. With almost 6 BILLION dollars spent on the USA election campaigns - we can surely spare a little for supporting our tiger population.

Read about us

  • News Online
  • RSS
  • eBulletin
  • Green Diary
  • Printed Newsletter

Contact us

Email: info@worldlandtrust.org
Tel: +44 (0)1986 874422
More details »

Follow us

Follow on Facebook  Follow on Twitter  Follow on Linkedin  Follow on GooglePlus  Follow on YouTube